Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (2023)

Is Classic American still open?

Current Status: >> CLOSED <<
(keep reading to learn what happened)

Season: 4 | View All Season 4 Episodes
Original Episode Air Date: January 28, 2011
Classic American Address: 691 Rt 109 West Babylon, NY 11704

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (1)

Episode Recap

Classic American was a West Babylon, New York restaurant featured on Season 4 of Kitchen Nightmares.

Though the Classic American Kitchen Nightmares episode aired in January 2011, the actual filming and visit from Gordon Ramsay took place much earlier in November 2010.

It was Kitchen Nightmares Season 4 Episode 2.

In this episode of Kitchen Nightmares, we head to the Classic American restaurant in Long Island.

Classic American is a restaurant located in West Babylon, New York, owned by waitress duo Colleen and Naomi.

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (2)

Colleen and Naomi bought the restaurant in 2000 for almost $700,000, so they have a lot of debt to make up.

Today the restaurant is failing due to low turnouts, low supplies, and high staff stress.

Dominick, the boyfriend of one of the owners, is supposedly the manager.

However, he doesn’t do a great job.

To make matters worse, the owners are struggling with family issues in addition to the financial woes facing the restaurant.

Gordon Ramsay enters the nearly empty Classic American restaurant and is greeted by owners Naomi and Colleen.

They are nervous talking to Ramsay, who asks them why they think the restaurant is failing.

When Gordon goes to order food, he finds out that the menu is vast and features over 100 items, which surprises him.

(Video) Kitchen Nightmares | Are They Still Open?

This is also a red flag as there’s no way a restaurant can have fresh ingredients for that many dishes.

Gordon decides to order the calamari, mac and cheese, and their specialty “The Bomb” burger.

Gordon notes that it looks like Kraft when the mac and cheese arrives.

Now, I do love me some Kraft mac ‘n cheese, but it’s not what you’d expect from a restaurant.

It doesn’t get much better, either – the calamari is frozen, and their specialty burger comes out unseasoned.

At one point, he asks the waitress to feel his food to see how bad it is:

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (3)

To put things politely, Gordon Ramsay is less than impressed with his meal from Classic American.

Gordon tells the owners that their motto, “Just like mom made,” is insulting to mothers.

In fact, Gordon is amazed that the staff finds the food edible.

The team is very open to Gordon’s suggestions.

They want to see the restaurant succeed, but there are a lot of problems to overcome.

For example, Classic American uses handwritten tickets because their computer system is down, which just isn’t very efficient.

During dinner service, Classic America runs out of ground beef.

They also do not have enough plates, silverware, or menus.

They keep running low on supplies and there’s just basically a lot going wrong with the restaurant’s logistics.

Colleen cannot handle the stress and walks out during dinner.

Gordon follows her to see what is going on.

She is highly emotional and is afraid of losing the restaurant.

Gordon decides to play an anonymous question game, and it is revealed that the waitresses are on their phones during dinner service.

Gordon also finds out that Naomi is a pushover, and Dom, the acting manager throws a fit.

(Video) Gordon Ramsay Revisits Old Restaurants From Kitchen Nightmares

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (4)

Gordon calls him out about the Classic American restaurant not having enough supplies.

He tells the owners they need to toughen up if they want the Classic American restaurant to succeed.

Gordon decides to switch the owner’s roles because he wants to make sure they are serious before he invests his time in their restaurant.

The celebrity chef teaches the kitchen staff how to make a slider special.

Gordon catches a waitress texting, but she quickly corrects her behavior.

The restaurant is full that evening for dinner service, but there are not enough menus for all of the customers.

The restaurant begins to pick up, but Colleen is still feeling overwhelmed.

Food keeps getting returned, and after someone sends back a dish of mushy vegetables, Gordon shuts down the restaurant.

He tells the owners changes must start immediately.

As part of that, Gordon gives the restaurant a facelift and revamps the whole menu.

He reduces the menu to half of its size, which makes it much easier for the Classic American owners to manage the inventory and reduce spoilage.

That night Colleen and Naomi step up, and Dom takes a step back.

As soon as service starts, Gordon catches the waitresses outside smoking cigarettes.

He quickly ushers them back inside.

Naomi begins multitasking, and the rest of the night runs smoothly.

When he leaves, Gordon Ramsay gives out hugs, as is normally the case (when the owners aren’t insane).

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (5)

So was the Kitchen Nightmares Classic American restaurant episode a success?

Keep reading our update to learn what happened next and if this West Babylon restaurant is still open in 2023 and beyond.

Classic American Update - What Happened Next?

Now that we’ve recapped the Classic American Kitchen Nightmares episode, let’s talk about what happened after Gordon Ramsay and his crew left West Babylon, NY.

(Video) Dr. Phil Asks Amy and Sammy About Their Behavior on "Kitchen Nightmares"

But before we get to where Classic American is in 2023, let’s first talk about Gordon’s second visit to the restaurant.

Gordon Ramsay Classic American revisit in Season 5

Thanks to Gordon’s changes, things seemed to be going better for Classic American.

Gordon revisited Classic American in Episode 5 of Season 5, which is the same episode where he revisited Downcity in Providence Rhode Island and Davide in Boston, Massachusetts.

When goes back to the restaurant, Gordon discovers that Naomi and Kevin are running the kitchen while Colleen is in charge of the front of the restaurant and interacts with customers.

Business is up a whopping 35% which is a huge improvement and helps the Classic American owners pay down their purchasing debt.

Gordon also orders some food, the meat loaf, and rates it a 10.5/10, which is high praise from the critical chef.

As a surprise, Gordon presents them with an award from Good Times Magazine – the Long Island’s Best Burger Award.

If you want to see the Classic American Gordon Ramsay revisit episode, it starts at around the 8:59 mark in this YouTube video:

Beyond Gordon’s praise, the Yelp reviews for the business seemed to be improved.

Though the overall Yelp rating was only 3.5 stars, a lot of the recent reviews seemed to be more positive.

Is the Classic American restaurant still open after Kitchen Nightmares?

Classic American closed for good in August 2013, which was a little over three years after the visit from Gordon Ramsay and Kitchen Nightmares.

In announcing the closure, Colleen posted the following message on Facebook:

Yes it’s true.

I would like to thank all of our employees, friends, family and loyal customers for all there support and patronage for the last 13 years.

It has been our pleasure to serve you!!

Thank you!!

We will still be offering catering services and can be reached through Facebook.

Here’s a screenshot of the Facebook post in case it gets deleted:

Classic American Kitchen Nightmares Update – Still Open in 2023? (6)

Even though the restaurant wasn’t able to achieve long-term success, three years is a pretty good run given the state of the restaurant when Gordon Ramsay visited it.

(Video) Times Owners DISRESPECTED Gordon! (Kitchen Nightmares)

For a time, the old Classic American West Babylon location in Long Island was occupied by a new restaurant called Blu Mediterranean!.

Reviews for the restaurant seemed good as it has a four-star rating on Yelp.

However, as of late 2022, Blu Mediterranean is now closed.

The building seems to be empty for now – I will update this post if I learn about a new business moving in.

The old Classic American building was also listed for sale on Loopnet in February 2022, though the listing is now closed.

Here’s an interactive embed that shows the old Classic American restaurant West Babylon location in the most recent image from Google Maps street view:

Why did Classic American close?

When the Classic American owners closed the restaurant, they didn’t share a specific reason why the restaurant closed.

However, they did post a note saying that they would still be offering catering services, so it seems like they weren’t totally getting out of the cooking industry.

Final thoughts on the Classic American restaurant

Overall, Classic American had a solid three-year run after the visit from Gordon Ramsay.

Business was up and Gordon Ramsay really liked the food when he revisited the restaurant in Season 5.

Unfortunately, it would not last and the Classic American restaurant closed in August 2013, around three years after Gordon’s visit.

For a time, the old Classic American West Babylon location was occupied by another restaurant, but that restaurant is now also closed.

The building has been listed for sale multiple times, so it will be interesting to see what eventually ends up at that property.

If you want to see some other nearby Long Island Kitchen Nightmares episodes, you can also check out my updates for Peter’s Italian Restaurant in Babylon, Seascape Inn in Islip, and The Mixing Bowl in Bellmore.

Thanks for reading!

👉 Read other Season 4 updates:

  • Next episodePJ’s Steakhouse update
  • Previous episodeSpanish Pavillion update

More Information

What did you think about the Classic American episode of Kitchen Nightmares? I'd love it if you shared your thoughts on the episode in the comments below!

You can also click the buttons below to share this post!

And don't forget to check out all of the other Kitchen Nightmares updates.

Watch Kitchen Nightmares Episodes at Amazon

(Video) What Happened to Sammy/Sabatiello's from Kitchen Nightmares?

Last updated: 2023-01-14 06:54


Is Kitchen Nightmare Classic American still open? ›

Classic American closed in September 2013. It was the last restaurant on Long Island visited by Ramsay to remain open (every restaurant he remade on Long Island has since closed).

Did Classic American restaurant close? ›

The popular Classic American Restaurant in West Babylon has closed down and been put up for sale, owners confirmed via Facebook this week. “Yes it's true,” noted co-owner Colleen Gaertner on the business' Facebook page.

What happened to American Classic? ›

Their demise is being described as a “cash flow” issue. The brand experienced declining sales in 2016, hoped to bolster things with OE sales and when that didn't materialize, the funds weren't there to keep things rolling. Bill Shook of American Classic... going really wide back in 2013.

What happened to Jim and Jeff? ›

Jim and Jeff permanently closed Capri on Sunday, September 8, 2019. The following year they sold it to a new owner, who re-opened it with the same name, menu and décor. As of 2021 it is still in business. Jim and Jeff's Facebook page is still up and you can see their "goodbye" videos.

What is the most successful restaurant after Kitchen Nightmares? ›

Gordon Ramsey isn't enough to save many of the restaurants on Kitchen Nightmares, but he did it for these ten!
Here are 10 of them that are still very much alive and well.
  1. 1 Café Hon.
  2. 2 Spin-A-Yarn Steakhouse. ...
  3. 3 Luigi's D'Italia. ...
  4. 4 Leone's. ...
  5. 5 Yanni's Greek Cuisine. ...
  6. 6 Olde Hitching Post Restaurant & Tavern. ...
Oct 1, 2019

What replaced Kitchen Nightmares? ›

They took a break from Kitchen Nightmares and came back with a revamped show called 24 Hours to Hell and Back, which has been renewed for its second season. It's crazy to think Gordon cancelled Kitchen Nightmares over one of the restaurants! What do you think about this?


1. What Happened to Burger Kitchen? (And Alan Saffron's connection to the criminal world)
2. What happened to Blackberry's from Kitchen Nightmares?
3. 'Award Winning' Meatload Doesn't Impress Gordon | Kitchen Nightmares
(All In The Kitchen)
4. TOP 5 Restaurants That Are Still Open | Kitchen Nightmares
(Kitchen Nightmares)
5. Kitchen Nightmares US S06E06 - Revisited No. 8
6. Iconic Season 1 Episodes | Kitchen Nightmares
(Kitchen Nightmares)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Edwin Metz

Last Updated: 02/18/2023

Views: 5861

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Edwin Metz

Birthday: 1997-04-16

Address: 51593 Leanne Light, Kuphalmouth, DE 50012-5183

Phone: +639107620957

Job: Corporate Banking Technician

Hobby: Reading, scrapbook, role-playing games, Fishing, Fishing, Scuba diving, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Edwin Metz, I am a fair, energetic, helpful, brave, outstanding, nice, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.